1. Listing & first impressions
- Your listing description isn't complete yet. It scores 3/10, so check the bounty section of your listing and you'll see exactly what to improve.
- Your website takes me straight to the login page. Add a landing page so I can see what the app does before I sign in. Right now, even after testing, I still can't say clearly what I'd use it for.
2. Sign up & dashboard (test 1 & 2)
- Google sign-in works fine.
- The home dashboard shows a lot at once: Start with a pay, Enter your savings, Calendar, CSV import, Connect to Todoist. Make the one main action obvious. Picture someone tunnel-visioned at 100% zoom: what's the first thing they see and do?
- After adding a pay, the homepage still says "Welcome to your personal headquarters." It should react to what I've already done.
- Navigation is hard overall. I struggled to find most sections.
- Tip: map out your perfect customer journey. Landing page → sign in → log a pay → … → upgrade. Then design every screen around that path.
3. Pay Splitter (test 3)
- Currency: it set my net pay in Australian dollars and never asked me. I couldn't change it. Auto-detect it, but always let people change it as a fallback.
- Too many fields at once: net pay, pay period, payment date, bills reserve, investments. Maybe you need all of them, but ask one at a time.
- Labels like "bills reserve" and "net amount actually received" aren't clear for non-professionals.
- Bug: I switched to another tab mid-entry and came back to find everything I'd filled in was gone. Either warn about unsaved changes or auto-save a draft.
- "Record pay only after receiving it": add a Schedule option (e.g. a checkbox) so I can log a future salary or backdate a past one.
- Saving works 👍
- Move validation/warning messages to a notification in the top right. Middle-bottom feels out of place.
4. Bank accounts, savings & investments (test 4)
- I couldn't figure out where to add these at all. Make this much easier to find.
5. Work Tracker & fitness (test 5)
- With everything unlocked, the problem is the same: I have to learn how to set up exercise, Todoist and finance all at once. That's a lot.
- Connecting to other apps is the right move, since it skips the setup work. Lean into that.
- Give each dashboard (Work Tracker, gym, etc.) one main CTA the first time someone opens it: log something or connect your tool.
- Calendar: add Google Calendar sync.
6. Syncing & saving (test 6 & 7)
- Same browser, signed out and back in → data saved correctly. ✅
- Bug: logged in on my phone with the same Google account and my Pay Splitter data wasn't there. Cross-device sync seems broken.
- Closing the tab logged me out. Remember my session so I don't have to log in every single time.
- After Sign out, it sends me to the login with email option. Small thing.
7. Layout on mobile & desktop (test 8)
- Desktop is fine. Mobile looks basically the same, and pretty good. Colours look great.
- Bug: on mobile, once I open the navigation I can't close it without picking a section.
- Inconsistency: light mode shows a normal icon, dark mode shows a ☀️ emoji. Go all in on emojis or don't use them at all.
- Consider one dashboard per area: finance, productivity, fitness (which already exists). Each one says: "Here you can do this, this and that."
8. Pricing & payments
- Pro at A$5/month is very reasonable and makes sense. Show it in my local currency though, as I had no idea what A$5 is.
- Stripe checkout: trusted, standard, works.
- Almost everything beyond the basics is Pro. That's fine, but let me use something first. Show the value, then ask to pay.
9. Your answers
- Broken or confusing? Unsaved form data loss, cross-device sync, mobile nav. Mostly it's confusing rather than broken.
- Data saves correctly? Yes on the same device, not across devices.
- Easy to navigate? Not yet.
- Performance? No issues, loading is fine.
10. The biggest thing: get people started small
Right now it's all-or-nothing: either I log everything in full detail, or it's too much and I log nothing. Most people will log nothing.
- Let people do one small thing first, and usage grows from there.
- Use your AI right on the home dashboard: "Where do we start?" → Log a workout / Log a saving / Log a pay. A few simple options, then let the AI guide them.
Bottom line
The idea is sound and the core works and logs correctly. Your challenge is onboarding: make it dead simple to start, and the rest will follow.

